Retrospective:
Summer Workshop
22nd-23rd June 2023

In June of 2023, we held our first summer workshop on the theme ‘The Future of Groups’ in Leeds, England.

Attendees comprised UKRI Future Leadership Fellows (FLF) and their research teams from a wide range of disciplines and research organisations. Research areas ranged from disaster and emergency collective responses to occupational constructs in archaeology and construction, and from user trust in AI healthcare to human-animal or human-plant interactions, and many more.

The aim of the workshop was to provide an opportunity for discussion and collaboration between members on the network, explore the directions it might grow in and the resource it can become. The workshop was hosted at The Lost and Found Club and The Queens Hotel, Leeds, and involved a variety of activities including whole group discussion, collaborative group tasks, and presentations by guest speakers.

This retrospective report provides an overview of those activities, as well as a summary of the Summer Workshop’s outputs and feedback we received from the post-workshop survey. Its findings suggest that the Summer workshop was enjoyed by its attendees and that there is a desire for future events involving FLF’s and their teams, as well as events that include community practitioners or other non-academics.

Members of the Groups Network
(Back row, left-right: Dr Yunhe Tong (University of Edinburgh), Dr Guillermo Diaz de Liano (MOLA), Ellen Falkingham (University of Oxford), Dr Martha Newson (Universities of Oxford and Greenwich), Sam Vo (University of Edinburgh), Venetia Brown (The Open University), Dr Giulia Palazzolo (University of Warwick), Dr Linus Peitz (University of Kent), Dr Uche Okpara (University of Greenwich).
Front row, left-right: Retno Larasati (The Open University), Sayaka Hinata (University of Edinburgh), Dr Anne Templeton (University of Edinburgh), Kat Helming (University of Warwick))

Our Attendees

15

4

Attendees

Future Leader
Fellows

Universities and Organisations Represented

8

Post Doctoral
Researchers

3

PhD Students

Workshop Activities

Solving The Questions of the Future

In small, interdisciplinary groups, we created mind maps as we explored what the biggest questions faced by groups in the future might be. We then perused the mind maps of the other groups and voted using post-its on the questions we wanted to discuss in more depth as a whole group discussion. We also later engaged in a full group discussion of the role of our research on groups in the future research landscape, and how The Groups Network might be used to inform our research, facilitate knowledge exchange, and share our findings.

Other Collaborative Group Activities:

  • Introductory elevator pitches from all network members

  • A ‘speed dating’ activity – 1-to-1 conversations, rotating to a new partner at timed intervals, an opportunity to get to know each other and our research at speed.

  • A competitive small group mock research proposal and funding application presentation

  • A research sandbox – an open research discussion and space for collaborative opportunities to emerge

Guest Speakers

End of Workshop Summary

For our final activity, we split up into small groups to reflect on our discussions and identify the common themes that had arisen, the needs of the Groups Network and its members, and the skills possessed within the group. We then discussed our thoughts as a whole.

From this, we identified themes, needs and skills.

Refined summary of member mindmaps
  • Cooperation and conflict resolution 

  • Connection and community 

  • Interdisciplinary and international, attending to cultural nuances  

  • Impact (societal and academic) 

  • Change/transformation
     

  • Technology and social groups 

Themes

Refined summary of member mindmaps

Needs

  • Regular and sustained interactions to share ideas and foster collaboration, speakers, allowing space for feedback on ideas and research (‘think tank’, sandbox) 

  • Training on communication with diverse audiences, especially ensuring accurate understanding

  • Resources that we can access to collaborate, share skills, share networks and contacts 

  • Early career researcher needs: meeting like-minded people from other disciplines, training for grant writing and finding grants

  • Engagement with a diverse range of voices including those outside of academia

  • Mentoring abilities 

  • Interdisciplinary knowledge

  • Diverse Research Tools and Experience

  • Communicating  

  • Organisational and Project Management Skills

Skills

Feedback

Feedback on the summer workshop was collected during group discussion as part of the end-of-workshop summary exercise, and also through an anonymous post-workshop online survey circulated the week following the event.

What the attendees enjoyed about
The Summer workshop

  • The interdisciplinary, creative, and collaborative environment

  • The opportunity to hear from voices both inside and outside academia

  • The opportunity to network and develop collaboration skills

  • The format of the activities and the engagement they fostered

  • The organisation of the event

  • The choice of venue and location

“What did you enjoy about the Summer Workshop?” -
What attendees said:

  • “The organisation and the atmosphere were very good, despite the fact that people met in person for the first time. You could tell toward the end that this was a very fruitful first step to arranging deeper collaboration and exchange.”

  • “[the workshop] required active engagement and encouraged us all to mix and share ideas. It also felt like a relaxed and collaborative environment that fostered discussion and ideas (rather than simply showcasing them).”

  • “I enjoyed seeing how we can learn from each other”

  • “The workshop was really well organised and managed. It was highly dynamic and enjoyable. Intellectually stimulating as well. Wonderful selection of speakers. Great location, excellent choices for accommodation and food.”

  • “I enjoyed seeing how groups are explored in different ways”

  • “Interesting minds at the front of their fields. Collegiate environment. Not the 'typical' academic space, more creative and less competitive.”

  • “I can reflect my study's usefulness and potential from other fields people's feedback.”

  • “I enjoyed meeting others and learning about their research to find common connections and interests”

  • “The very nice people I met, the super interesting talks and discussions. I am very interested in the themes that we covered during the various activities, and I found these activities very enjoyable and stimulating. In general, I really like the idea of the Groups Network.”

  • “Good mix of people, shared values and differences. Great talks, topics and sharing of ideas.”

  • “An opportunity to interact with people and share different perspectives for our research.”

  • “I enjoyed that we had both academic and non-academic speakers”

  • “I enjoyed meeting like-minded people with similar values, discussing and getting inspiration about the topic of group structures”

What the survey tells us about enjoyment and longer term collaboration

Of all respondents to the post-workshop survey (8 of 15 attendees), all responded that they enjoyed the summer workshop ‘a lot’ or ‘a great deal’, and on a Likert scale of 1 (strongly disagree) - 10 (strongly agree), all respondents indicated that they would be likely to recommend the Groups Network to a colleague with shared research interests, with over 85% of respondents providing scores of 8 or higher.

However, survey responses also indicate that there is some uncertainty whether the Summer Workshop helped attendees develop collaborative opportunities beyond the event, although generally, most responses to questions relating to this were positive.

Of all responses to the question ‘Did the Summer Workshop help you develop collaborative opportunities?’, with answers on a Likert scale with 5 values ranging from ‘Definitely no’ to ‘Definitely yes’, 25% of respondents responded ‘Might or might not’, 50% responded ‘Probably yes’, and 25% ‘Definitely yes’

Some respondent explanations, pointed to collaborative opportunities as being something that could arise from medium-longer term engagement with The Groups Network, and that it was difficult to tell the extent of the benefits of the workshop as regards collaborative opportunities so soon after it had occurred. This reiterates the need expressed during the end-of-workshop summary activity for regular and sustained interactions to share ideas and foster collaboration between members of The Groups Network.

‘Did the Summer Workshop help you develop collaborative opportunities?’ -
What attendees said:

  • "I believe that my medium-long term participation in the group will help me improve my research, although at the moment, it might be a bit early to say as some of my research topics are a bit far from the group's research interests"

  • “Not sure this was the aim. Rather it opened the door to potentially effective collaborations”

  • ‘I think it is too early to say how being part of the Groups Network will make me more effective at my job, but there are at least two aspects of the Summer Workshop that I believe will have a positive impact: (i) thanks to the Summer Workshop, I have established contact with researchers from other disciplines working on different projects, to whom I can refer for my own research and, hopefully, for more direct collaborations; (ii) I have been introduced to new (and exciting) research and work possibilities. Moreover, being part of a group and working in teams I think helps research in general.’

What the network would like to see at future events

  • ‘A point we can keep coming home to’ – reliable, regular meetings

  • More time to network, hear about each other’s research, and find opportunities to collaborate – perhaps a specific communication and cooperation event or a ‘think tank’ space

  • Speakers

    • From a range of academic and non-academic backgrounds and disciplines, including transformative change

    • With practical (non-academic) experience in our research areas

    • To explore opportunities for collaboration with and who are likely to benefit from our work and can say what they need from us

  • ‘A virtual public living room’ – an online space for chatting, contributing, and sharing resources

  • Opportunities to develop our skills and collaborate whilst doing so (e.g. communication training)

  • Tight themes for each event to be structured around

  • Name tags or information about event attendees and activities prior to the event

  • Rotation of organisers, locations and grant applications 

Who we would like to include as part of the Groups Network in the future

In the post-workshop survey a majority of respondents also expressed that they would be interested in attending future events that include community practitioners or other non-academics (75%), and in future conferences or workshops for FLF Fellows and their teams (63%). With some also expressing interest in a conference or workshop which would included others beyond the FLF network, and one participant explicitly suggesting ongoing activities to strengthen the research group.

During the group discussion, it was also determined that including members from outside of academia in The Groups Network would depend on UKRI funding, but there may be a possibility for us to have honorary members (including former postdocs, etc). Depending on interest this may be something we explore in the future.